So, you know that iconic crunchy, peanut-buttery candy bar that we all loved as kids? Yeah, Butterfinger. Now, what if I told you there’s a cocktail that tastes just like it? Enter the Butterfinger Shot—a dessert-like drink that’s perfect for your next party, or a casual night in when you’re craving something fun and sweet (and let’s face it, who isn’t?).
In this article, I’m diving into why the Butterfinger Shot is the cocktail you never knew you needed but won’t be able to stop thinking about once you try it. Don’t worry, I’ll be your guide every step of the way.
What is a Butterfinger Shot, Anyway?
Let’s kick this off with the basics. The Butterfinger Shot is a decadent, creamy cocktail that mimics the flavor of the famous candy bar. It’s got that perfect balance of sweet, nutty, and just the right amount of crunchy (in liquid form, of course).
So, how do you make this sweet little masterpiece? Well, brace yourself—it’s easier than you think, and you don’t have to be some high-end bartender to pull it off. With just a few simple ingredients, you’re in business.
Ingredients for the Perfect Butterfinger Shot:
- 1 oz. Baileys Irish Cream (it’s all about the creamy base)
- 1 oz. Frangelico (for that nutty, hazelnut twist)
- 1 oz. Butterscotch Schnapps (this brings in the sweet, golden goodness)
- 1/2 oz. Peanut Butter Whiskey (because, why not?)
- Chocolate syrup (for that extra sweetness and maybe a little drizzle for the flair)
Now that you’ve got the goods, it’s time to bring the magic together.
How to Make a Butterfinger Shot:
- Grab your shaker: You’ll want to put everything in there. Start with the Baileys, Frangelico, Butterscotch Schnapps, and the Peanut Butter Whiskey. I mean, seriously, what could go wrong with these flavor combos?
- Add ice: A little chill never hurt anyone, right? Give it a good shake—really get that creamy, nutty flavor working together.
- Strain into a glass: No need to get fancy here. Just pour it into your shot glass. But hey, feel free to use a rocks glass if you’re feeling extra.
- Drizzle with chocolate syrup: This part’s optional, but come on, it adds to the experience. Plus, it’s a sweet touch.
Now, stand back and admire your creation. Admire is the keyword because let’s face it, this drink looks as good as it tastes.
Why You Should Try the Butterfinger Shot
Okay, so I’ve given you the recipe and the “how-to,” but I bet you’re still wondering why this drink deserves a spot in your next hangout session. Let me break it down.
1. It’s a Flavor Explosion in a Glass
When you take a sip of the Butterfinger Shot, it’s like your taste buds go on a roller coaster ride. The Baileys gives it that smooth, creamy kick, while the Frangelico adds that warm, nutty edge. The peanut butter whiskey? Totally the game changer, adding the same peanut butter punch that makes the Butterfinger candy bar so iconic. You might even find yourself whispering “wow” after the first sip.
2. Dessert in Shot Form
Who says you can’t have dessert AND a drink? If you love sweet, creamy concoctions (who doesn’t?), the Butterfinger Shot is basically a candy bar in a glass. It’s got that perfect balance of indulgent and luxe, and let’s be real—dessert shots are underrated.
3. It’s a Crowd-Pleaser
Think about it: you’ve got guests over, and you’re trying to impress them with something unique. You could whip out the same old cocktails, or you could give them a Butterfinger Shot and watch the room light up. It’s fun, it’s familiar (hello, nostalgia), and it’s guaranteed to start a conversation. Trust me, people will ask, “What’s in that shot?” and you’ll feel like the coolest bartender ever. 😎
Pro Tip: Customize Your Butterfinger Shot
I love a good twist on a classic, so why not personalize your Butterfinger Shot to suit your style? Here are a few variations you can try, depending on what vibe you’re going for:
- Add a touch of whipped cream: You know, to take the “dessert” factor to the next level. It’ll give it that extra creamy, indulgent finish.
- Switch up the whiskey: If you’re not sold on peanut butter whiskey, you could sub in regular whiskey or even bourbon. But FYI, it won’t taste quite the same—so don’t blame me if it’s not exactly like a Butterfinger candy bar.
- Go wild with garnishes: Try crumbling up some Butterfinger pieces and sprinkling them on top. Because why not have the real deal in there too, right?
Pairing the Butterfinger Shot
Now, what goes well with a shot of Butterfinger? It’s a good question, and I’ve got a few ideas to make sure your shot experience is next level.
Snacks to Pair:
- Chocolate fondue: Chocolate and peanut butter? Yeah, we’re making this a match made in heaven. Add a variety of fruits or marshmallows for dipping. A little extra sweetness never hurt anyone.
- Peanut Butter Pretzels: Got a salty craving to balance out all that sweetness? Peanut butter pretzels are your answer. Trust me, the salty-sweet combo is chef’s kiss.
The Right Mood:
- Game night? A round of Butterfinger Shots for everyone.
- Relaxing with friends? Pour a shot, kick back, and chat about anything and everything.
- Celebration time? This is a celebratory shot, perfect for toasts. It’s a dessert cocktail, after all!
Fun Facts About the Butterfinger Candy Bar
Okay, I know we’re here for the drink, but let’s take a quick detour into candy land for a second. Fun fact: The Butterfinger candy bar has been around since 1923. It’s basically a candy bar icon. But did you know it was originally made by a company called the Chicago-based Curtiss Candy Company? And guess who owns it now? That’s right, Nestlé. Talk about a candy legacy.
If that little bit of trivia didn’t make you smile, then maybe the fact that it’s been a beloved candy for decades will. There’s something about that crispy peanut butter center wrapped in chocolate that never gets old.
Why You’ll Keep Coming Back to the Butterfinger Shot
Let’s face it, there are a ton of drink recipes out there, but none that quite give you the same nostalgic, dessert-like satisfaction as the Butterfinger Shot. Whether you’re a fan of candy bars or just someone who enjoys a unique cocktail, this shot is all about having fun with your drinks and satisfying your sweet tooth in a way that’s totally unexpected.
Plus, it’s ridiculously easy to make, which is always a win in my book. Who wants to slave over a cocktail when you could be hanging out with your friends instead?
Final Thoughts: Take a Shot, Relive Your Childhood
So, whether you’re looking to impress your friends, satisfy your inner sweet tooth, or just find a new go-to party drink, the Butterfinger Shot is the answer. Grab your ingredients, give it a shake, and enjoy a candy-inspired cocktail that’s sure to become your new favorite.
And hey, next time you see a Butterfinger candy bar, you can’t help but think—that’s one shot I need to make again. 😉 Cheers!